Mynga

Blogform-i9

Form I-9 for new hires: what the employee fills in

Form I-9 for new hires: the employee completes Section 1 and shows documents, and the employer completes Section 2. Here are the parts, per USCIS.

Doan Thi My Nga3 min read

Share

Watercolour illustration of a closed plain booklet tied with a ribbon and a brass magnifying glass resting on it, with an orchid sprig beside it.
Contents

Form I-9 for new hires is the form that verifies the identity and employment authorization of individuals hired for employment in the United States. The employee completes Section 1 and shows documents. The employer completes Section 2 after examining them. USCIS says that both employees and employers (or authorized representatives of the employer) must complete the form.

Who fills in which part

The employee’s job is short: attest to work authorization in Section 1, then present acceptable documents to the employer. The employer’s job is longer, because it must judge the documents and record what it saw.

PartCompleted byWhat it covers
Section 1Employeeattest to their employment authorization
Section 2EmployerExamines documents and records the document information
Supplement APreparer or translatorOnly if one helped with Section 1
Supplement BEmployerReverification or rehire

In Section 2 the employer must examine the documents to determine whether they reasonably appear to be genuine and relate to the employee. Certain employers use a DHS-authorized alternative procedure to examine documents remotely, and those employers check a box in Section 2 to say so.

The four parts of the form

USCIS describes four parts. Most new hires only touch the first.

PageContentsKept in the employee’s file?
Page 1Section 1 and Section 2Yes
Page 2Lists of Acceptable DocumentsNo, employers do not need to retain this page
Page 3Supplement A, preparer or translatorOnly if one was used
Page 4Supplement B, reverification and rehireOnly if reverification or a documented rehire happens

The employer must give the employee the Lists of Acceptable Documents, either as a hard copy or as a hyperlink. That list is the place to check which documents are accepted before the first day.

Printing, signing and the edition date

The form is fillable, so the employee can type answers, but the signature blocks are different. USCIS says employers and employees using this fillable form must print and manually sign it, because the fillable version does not meet DHS standards for electronic systems under 8 CFR section 274a.2.

The edition date sits at the bottom of the form and instructions. The current edition is 01/20/25. Employers may also use an older 08/01/23 edition until its expiration date, which is 05/31/2027 or 07/31/2026 depending on the version, so a different edition date on the paper in front of you is not automatically a mistake. Employers using an electronic version had to update their systems to the 05/31/2027 version by 07/31/2026. Only employers in Puerto Rico may complete the Spanish-language form instead of the English one.

What happens to the form afterward

The completed form does not go to the government. USCIS says do not file Form I-9 with USCIS or ICE. The employer keeps it.

Employer dutyRule
Keep a form for each person on payrollRequired
Retention periodThree years after the date of hire, or one year after employment ends, whichever is later
InspectionAvailable to officials from DHS, the Department of Labor or the Department of Justice

Students and the questions to send

An F-1 student should know that USCIS says off-campus training employment must be authorized prior to starting any work by the Designated School Official and USCIS. The school official decides what your authorization is, and Form I-9 only records what you attest and show. For the employer side of a STEM OPT job, see STEM OPT and E-Verify: what to ask an employer. For job posts that mention sponsorship, see what no sponsorship in a job post means.

A short message to the hiring contact before day one keeps the paperwork calm:

Hello, before my start date I would like to confirm the Form I-9 process.
Will I complete Section 1 on the first day, and in person or remotely?
Could you send the Lists of Acceptable Documents so I can bring the right originals?

Verdict

Form I-9 for new hires splits cleanly: the employee attests in Section 1 and presents documents, and the employer examines them and completes Section 2. Ask the employer which documents and which process it uses, and ask your school official about training authorization, since they decide that part. The USCIS page lists the form, instructions and current edition.

Read the form and instructions yourself: open the USCIS Form I-9 page

Sources:USCIS: Employment Eligibility Verification (I-9), USCIS: Students and Employment.

MembershipVisa Jobs

US jobs that tell you if they sponsor.

  • Every posting states its visa stance
  • Filter by role, visa and state
  • Links to the employer's own listing

$8a month, cancel any time

See Visa Jobs

Join Visa Radar on Discord

A free community for people moving to the US on a J-1, F-1/OPT or work visa.

Free when you join

  • A job post every day
  • Answers to your visa questions
  • Wins from people on the same path
Join the server, free

Responses

Sign in to write a response

Keep reading

Send feedback